Paul is tied up with a pillow case over his head. Assuming his captor is Rob, he apologises for upsetting him and says he'd love to go on that trip with him. However, it's actually Toadie, or in this reality the "Toadfather", complete with ponytail and tattoos. The tattoo on his neck is of Angie.
PAUL: Is that your mother?
TOADIE: Have more respect for the dead... or you'll be joining them!
Toadie yells at Paul that repayment of debt is due with interest. Sonja comes in and Toadie calls her "Piranha"! She asks Paul why he has disobeyed her husband and tried to leave Erinsborough. Paul asks for a couple more days but Sonja says he's out of time. Toadie goes to strangle Paul but Paul asks if he really wants to do this in front of his pregnant wife. Sonja tells Toadie to give them a moment alone to see if Mr. Robinson has had a change of heart.
Number 28 (real timeline)
SUSAN: Can you go back to the bit about us?
PAUL: Oh, my life and death drama not entertaining enough for you, is it?!
Paul tells Susan that Karl didn't give up easily.
Limo (alternate timeline)
Susan is putting her clothes back on and says she's a terrible person; Phil doesn't deserve this. She just wanted something to happen in her life. She asks Karl what this means for their future and Karl says he's got a gig at 8!
SUSAN: Did you just want me because you can't have me?
KARL: Oh hey, no. No, no way, no way. I think we've established I can have you any time I want!
SUSAN: So that's it?
KARL: Lone wolves run free; second album, third track!
SUSAN: You... [picks up his guitar]
KARL: Oh, hey, hey, no, no... very careful.
SUSAN: Why? I'd be doing the world a favour. They wouldn't have to listen to your stupid lyrics any more!
KARL: They are very expensive. Can you afford to replace it? [Susan grabs his face] No, not the face! Not the face!SUSAN: If you ever set foot in Robinson street again!
KARL: You'll never see me again!
Susan returns home and finds Phil has cleaned the house and has written two whole chapters.
SUSAN: Which book? Lips of Peril or Under the Azure Moon?
PHIL: Something new; something Paul mentioned, funnily enough. It's about a woman who slips on spilt milk, loses her memory, doesn't remember anything since she was 16, then slowly falls in love with her husband again!
SUSAN: Bit far fetched!
Susan tries to confess what she's just done but Phil asks her to read something; he's dedicating the book to her. He apologises for the past few months but Susan suggests they both just put the past behind them. She looks relieved until Phil finds a guitar pick in her hair!
Susan runs after Phil, asking him to try to understand.
PHIL: Everything we had; our families, our lives together, our love, our trust... it's all gone. It means nothing. I mean, where do we go from here? How do we start again. I gave up everything for you. Everything. My family. Debbie doesn't speak to me. Hannah has never forgiven me. You're right; I don't understand. And I will never forgive you!
Number 28 (real timeline)
Susan looks shocked, and Karl tells Paul to go on. Paul says he and Sonja were finally alone.
Warehouse (alternate timeline)
Paul asks Sonja why she's doing this as she takes a bikini out of one of the many boxes.
SONJA: Do you know what this is?
PAUL: Of course, it's a bikini.
SONJA: A Rebeckini!
PAUL: A Rebecchichini? [Sonja slaps him with it]
SONJA: A Rebeckini!
PAUL: A Reb... Rebec... Rebec... [Sonja slaps him again!]
SONJA: A REBECKINI! Jarrod built this business from the ground up. Cast aside by his family as a teenager he was forced to live under horrendous conditions.
PAUL: Hang on, didn't he live with the Kennedys?
SONJA: Where he was subjected to tortures you could not possibly believe.
PAUL: Karl's music!
Sonja tells him Jarrod became a very rich man and people came to him for money and then turned their back on him. Paul says he's had time to think about the baby and he wants to make a go of it.
SONJA: Really? You seemed so sure before that you want nothing to do with us.
PAUL: To tell the truth I've always thought you were a bit of alright! Massive thorn in my side sometimes...
Sonja says she'll tell Jarrod to make off and then they can make a run for it, but he needs to transfer the money first. Paul gives her a pass code but it's incorrect so she yells for Jarrod. Toadie comes down the stairs with a gun bag.
PAUL: You don't want to do this in front of your wife or your baby.
TOADIE: Your baby mate, not mine. I've been shooting blanks for a while now! This on the other hand is fully loaded!
Rob drags Callum in and Callum asks what's going on.
PAUL: They're criminals. They're trying to extort me.
CALLUM: That's impossible.
ROB: Well why have they tied him up then?
CALLUM: I don't know. It could be like a fun party game like they used to play with my Uncle Mark.
ROB: Uncle Mark?
CALLUM: Yeah, he used to come round all the time until he... went missing on a fishing trip. Are you guys gangsters?!
TOADIE: How else are we gonna pay for your expensive stuff?
CALLUM: By running an incredibly successful bikini franchise!
ROB: Alright, alright, untie my father now or the octopus gets turned into calamari!
CALLUM: Is that really the best pun you could come up with?
Toadie unties Paul and Callum says his life is a lie.
Paul asks Rob what he was thinking following him. Rob wants to know why Paul is exacting so strange; what happened to his plans to divorce Terese?
ROB: And every time you're around me you flinch.
PAUL: No, you're imagining it.
ROB: Yeah well I heard what you said in the warehouse. Why would I kidnap you?
ROB: For what?
PAUL: Neglecting you when you were growing up.
ROB: But you were a great dad... to all of us.
PAUL: What happened to Cam, really? Why do you keep saying that it should have been you?
ROB: Because he died after giving me his kidney.
PAUL: That's not your fault, mate.
ROB: It's like talking to your evil twin or something.
PAUL: Yeah or I could be a time- traveller from a parallel universe!
Paul tries to prove it by taking out the device. He has to go back and put things the way they should be... but the device doesn't work. Rob laughs and thinks it's a Halloween prank so Paul plays along.
ROB: Oh, Dad...